
The following article is authored by Reuben Fleming of Demers•Law and reflects his views as its author. It is provided for general informational purposes and is not legal advice. If you require legal counsel please contact Reuben at 416-864-4871 or the firm at 416-224-1444.
Imagine that you own a flower shop, and a neighbouring café owner proposes that each week, if you supply fresh bouquets for their tables, they will let you take half of their unsold pastries at closing to give to your employees. You agree and start delivering the bouquets as scheduled, however you initially only take one or two of the dozens of unsold pastries each week.
Your neighbour notices this, so she starts giving the remainder of your portion of the unsold pastries to her staff. One week, you finally decide to take the entirety of your share of the pastries, and the next morning, your neighbour is shocked; she claims that your having repeatedly forgone the opportunity to take half of the pastries clearly communicates that you intended to waive your right to do so in the future. This scenario captures the essence of a ‘waiver’ in contract law.
A waiver occurs when a party to a contract is fully aware of their rights under that contract, but makes an unequivocal and conscious decision to forego reliance on one or more of those rights. One of the foundational Canadian cases laying out the test for waiver is Saskatchewan River Bungalows Ltd. v. Maritime Life Assurance Co., 1994 CanLII 100 (SCC), [1994] 2 SCR 490, in which, the SCC states that:
“Waiver will be found only where the evidence demonstrates that the party waiving had (1) a full knowledge of rights; and (2) an unequivocal and conscious intention to abandon them….” (pp. 500, Saskatchewan River Bungalows Ltd.)”
This may not seem very intuitive—many may assume that their rights under a contract are inherently enduring, but without language that protects against waiver, contractual rights could be vulnerable. Furthermore, make no mistake that, while communication of waiver must be clear, it need not be verbal or written. In Technicore Underground Inc. v. Toronto (City), 2012 ONCA 597 (CanLII), the court states at paragraph 63 that:
“…Communication can be formal or informal and it may be inferred from conduct. The overriding consideration in each case is whether one party communicated a clear intention to waive a right to the other party.”
As such, while this also may not seem intuitive, repeatedly not taking your share of the pastries in the aforementioned hypothetical could be enough to communicate, through conduct, a clear intention to forego one’s reliance on their right to do so.
A ‘no waiver’ clause functions to make clear that the parties to a contract agree that no representations or conduct will constitute a waiver of any rights under that contract, short of an explicit waiver, e.g. by written and signed notice. The effect of such a clause is that it locks the terms of an agreement in place such that failing to exercise a right under a contract does not result in a waiver of that right. In the commercial contracting context, no-waiver clauses are prudent because they protect against unintentional forfeiture of rights.
Disputes over waiver of rights are just one of many potential hazards that parties face when engaging in commercial contracts. This kind of issue might not stand out to business owners and operators, which is why it is good practice to get professional legal advice from a qualified lawyer in your jurisdiction before engaging in contractual relationships.
Reuben Fleming, J.D.