Skip to content

The Entire Agreement Clause

This article was authored by Reuben Fleming. It is provided for informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. For legal advice please contact Reuben at 416-864-4871 or the firm at 416-224-1444. Note also: this article uses AI generated images created pursuant to OpenAI’s terms of service.

An ‘entire agreement clause’ operates to limit the terms of an agreement to a specific document or set of documents. These clauses sometimes allow for changes to be made to an agreement, but typically require that such changes be made in writing and signed by all parties.

This can provide some security to everyone involved, as contracts and modifications to contracts can otherwise be created, not only in writing, but also orally or even implicitly. As such, an ‘entire agreement clause’ could, for example, protect a bakery against a supplier claiming that certain terms of their agreement were modified during a phone conversation months prior—it effectively locks the terms of the agreement in place and limits the addition of new terms. However, it pays to be aware that sometimes, the inclusion of an ‘entire agreement clause’ can interfere with other agreements, even retroactively.

In Constantine Enterprises Inc. v. Mizrahi (128 Hazelton) Inc., 2025 ONCA 710, the Court of Appeal for Ontario heard a challenge to a decision concerning the validity of an ‘entire agreement clause’.

The appellant had entered into an agreement of purchase and sale (APS) for a unit located within a building that was under development, and contained in this APS was an ‘entire agreement clause’. Prior to entering into the APS, the appellant entered into a supplementary agreement with the developer, ostensibly affording the appellant additional rights.

The builder went into receivership before the building’s completion, after which time, the receiver disclaimed the APS to maximize the recovery of assets. The appellant opposed this, relying on the supplementary agreement it had made with the developer prior to entering into the APS. The motion judge found the supplementary agreement to be unenforceable in virtue of the ‘entire agreement clause’ included in the APS.

The questions considered by the Court of Appeal regarding the ‘entire agreement clause’ were whether the motion judge erred in (1) determining that the clause was enforceable, and (2) in determining that neither public policy nor equity required non-enforcement of the clause.

The Court of Appeal held that the motion judge substantively applied the correct analysis in their decision by considering the surrounding circumstances and finding no reason to override the clear wording of the clause. The Court of Appeal also found that there was no policy reason to override the clause, and that the motion judge did not err in finding that there was no reason to give preference to the appellant’s debt over that of other creditors.

The Court of Appeal found the ‘entire agreement clause’ to be enforceable and dismissed the appeal with costs.

This case is illustrative, not only of the judiciary’s willingness to hold parties to their freely assumed contractual obligations, but also of how contracts made today may impact contracts made tomorrow, and even those made in the past. The fact that some clauses are almost ubiquitous could lead someone to the erroneous assumption that such clauses are superfluous legal jargon, when in reality, the history of disputes surrounding the subject matter they cover, as well as their efficacy in nipping those disputes in the bud, is often the rationale for their inclusion.

As a business owner, one may not know how the inclusion or exclusion of certain ‘standard language’ in contracts may help or harm their business interests, making it prudent to seek legal advice in such cases.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *